One of the useless things I learned at high school was the story of King Canute placing his throne to the beach (or at least, hiring a deckchair) and commanding the tide not to come in, to show the people that he had power over the sea (Or to show them he didn’t. Accounts vary). Either way he got wet feet. Unfortunately, the ‘Canute Method’ of Government seems to be back in fashion and it’s our very own government who are leading the way down to the seaside with their ‘Scrapping Premium’. As I’ve mentioned before this brilliant idea is that if you have a car over nine years old that you’ve owned at least a year you can scrap it, buy a new one and the Government will give you €2500 towards the cost. And you thought socialism was dead.
Now it appears the governments of Europe are all getting out their buckets and spades and heading off for the political seaside, none more enthusiastically than in the UK where the government is always on the lookout for ways to throw money at motorists. Apart from the silliness of encouraging people to destroy perfectly good cars, buy new ones, and then claim it is ‘for the Environment’ (I did not make that up) the ‘Business as usual’ mantra of the modern day Canutes misses one rather important point, namely that if we stay fixed to a car (read: ‘oil’) based transport system, we are simply delaying the inevitable. Oil is running out, and ‘Peak Oil’, the point at which demand begins to exceed supply, is no longer just being muttered amongst pot-smoking yurt dwellers, but is becoming a common phrase amongst amongst economists and transport planners. Their consensus: cheap oil is a thing of the past, the price dropped wit demand as the recession hit, but there are concerns that this recession is merely a dress rehearsal for what happens later when the demand for oil from recovering global economies sends prices soaring. One businessman has already said that Americans could face paying ten dollars for a gallon of petrol. What looks like a turning tide could in fact be a Tsunami over the horizon.
Canute gave up trying to turn the tide, and moved on. Instead of playing with sandcastles the governments and car builders could be working together to make a transport network for the future, where people don’t have to rely on cars. They won’t of course: they will just present a make believe future of cars running on batteries while making ever more gas guzzlers, but while they do, the grown-ups can be planning ahead. There are lots of very useful books and and blogs with practical ideas for changing our lifestyles in the face of a possible future there oil is very expensive indeed. I’m not talking about building a fortress in the wilderness and eating mushrooms, more making adjustments to wean us off depending on oil, directly or indirectly. As a family we’re looking at the possibilities, and I’ll probably blog about that as and when it happens. We’re already discovering that life gets richer when we just make a start.
Ironically I expect a lot of people will call us ‘prophets of doom’, but it beats sitting on a beach and shouting at the waves.

8 comments
Comments feed for this article
March 20, 2009 at 3:17 pm
Nico
You’re right, the governments keep making “business as usual” comments (and actions) while heading for the abyss.
Another problem is the politically apathetic majority that puts up with everything instead of breaking out in revolt.
March 20, 2009 at 8:51 pm
WestfieldWanderer
Far from wondering where the next gallon of petrol is coming from, we (that is, those who survive that long) are more likely to be wondering where the next meal is coming from. Modern agriculture relies on producing enough food for for us in the “Minority World”, as Dervla Murphy calls us, by massive use of petro-chemicals.
I read somewhere that the last time that the British Isles were self sufficient for food was at the time of the Civil War. Population at the time was about 6 million. A tenth of the current population.
Not only Peak Oil, but Peak Population.
March 21, 2009 at 1:38 pm
velochick
The only time we get ‘self sufficient’ is when we have a war going on and we have to ‘Dig for Victory’. We should always be prepared. It doesn’t make sense that we aren’t self- sufficient enough. I think a strong country is a self-sufficient country but I suppose we don’t get ‘good financial deals or backing’ if we don’t ‘trade’ with other countries. In Kent it is bad enough being in prime Apple country and we get loads of American, yes, American ‘special relationship’ apples.
It is commonsense that we will run out of things if everyone uses it but this is the Age of Stupid after all.
We tend to ‘react’ when it is too late. The Population issue isn’t being dealt with enough either.
March 21, 2009 at 1:45 pm
velochick
Yes, this ‘business as usual’ stuff is ridiculous. We ARE heading towards the abyss. The environment issue should be headlines. But no, that’s boring isn’t it and won’t sell the papers!
March 24, 2009 at 1:40 pm
Andy in Germany
Thanks for the comments…
I think the other issue is that if we stop believing the ‘business as usual’ story, then we’ll stop buying the unsustainable stuff business make, and as they pay for the media, the media plays their tune…
We’ll leave them to play and get ready.
April 16, 2009 at 1:09 am
Simon
Related: The mayor of Mannheim initiated a ‘scrapping bonus’ for… BIKES!
You’ll get lousy 50€ for your old bike if you buy a new one, but only if you live in Mannheim.
‘Abwrackprämie für Fahrräder‘ (text in German)
July 17, 2009 at 8:13 am
The Greenwash « People Powered
[...] The new Greenwash, coming to a town near you. And if you don’t drive the car companies will take your money anyway. [...]
November 27, 2009 at 10:07 pm
Kopf an, Motor Aus. « People Powered
[...] long-term, and the cynic in me resurfaces when I remember this is the same government that was paying people to buy cars earlier this year, but at least there’s a growing awareness that getting people walking and [...]