I can imagine the meeting where this was discussed:
“We need to add a few kilometres of bike lane to keep the greenies happy. Put a white line along this road here.”
“It’ll be tight with two-way traffic, can we make it one way?”
“No, that would slow down traffic.”
“Well, we’ll have to take out the parking”
“Don’t even think about it”
Pity the poor transport planner. There is no way you can fit traffic in both directions, and a cycle lane, and space for residents parking on a road this narrow without someone getting the short end of the arrangement, and naturally you can’t expect Mercedes Man to drive a detour of almost a hundred metres to make the street more liveable. There are similar cycle lanes in this part of Stuttgart, including about a kilometre of lanes, broken by roundabouts every two hundred metres, where the cycle lane stops abruptly, spitting you into traffic, and then starts again the other side.
On the other hand, the drivers I encountered seemed quite used to a bike riding outside of the bike lane, so I guess it’s normal for them. Stuttgart also does seem to have worked out that a red cycle lane – which is equivalent to a blue lane in Denmark, and gives bikes travelling along it priority at junctions- is a good thing to remind motorists that cyclists have right of way, which puts them a few decades ahead of Ostfildern.
I wrote this before we moved and planned to post automatically, typically, not only did that not happen, but Karl at Do The Right Thing beat me to it with with a more entertaining version in Edinburgh.


8 comments
Comments feed for this article
July 1, 2009 at 7:51 am
anna
There are many similar examples in Vienna. And the bike lanes that are actually wide enough are often used for double parking (illegally of course). Here are some pictures from Vienna. They are very proud of the 1000km of “bicycle infrastructure” (mostly only a sign beside the road anyway):
pictures of narrow designs – http://cyclingisgoodforyou.blogspot.com/2009/02/positioning-on-road.html
about maintenance of bike lanes – http://cyclingisgoodforyou.blogspot.com/2009/03/bike-lanes-anyone.html
I tend to not use such bike lanes myself if they are to narrow or otherwise dangerous. Of course you receive a lot of honking then.
July 1, 2009 at 10:31 pm
John . Dublin Ireland
We have the same sort of Cycle Lanes in Dublin,where if you are passing a load of Parked Cars you have to keep well out in case you are Doored by Passengers getting out of Cars. Those Roundabouts are Dangerous to Cyclists Cars come at you from all angles. They just Copied the Cycle Lanes of the UK in Order not to put the Motorist at an inconvenience. The Cars just Park on our Cycle Lanes they are ignored knowing the Police will not do anything about it. They have put in ASL ,Advanced Stop Lines for about a Year but the Cars just ignore them. It is all very Token our Infrastructure in Ireland. We should have Segregated Cycle Lanes like the Netherlands but have maybe two in the whole of Dublin.
July 2, 2009 at 10:01 am
Nick
Sometimes I forget how lucky I am to be in the Netherlands. I sometimes come across a few bike lane idiocies, but not often. And it’s even rare for the bike lane not to be separated off from the road completely. During my 12Km commute to and from work, I only cycle on a bike lane that’s part of a road for around 500 metres – and even having to do that is fairly unusual around here; I’m just unlucky, I guess.
July 3, 2009 at 9:26 am
Andy in Germany
It’s pretty hopeless isn’t it? They are getting better here, but it’s slow.
@Nick: That’s encouraging as I’ll be cycling in the NL soon. BTW Where do I get decent cycleway maps?
July 3, 2009 at 10:39 am
Nick
Halfords, local bike shops sometimes, the VVV (Dutch tourist organisation). The simplest way is to tell me what areas you need them for and I’ll get them for you.
July 3, 2009 at 10:49 am
Nick
Alternatively, go to http://www.vvv.nl and click on the green bar towards the bottom of the home page labelled GA TOCH FIETSEN. It will take you through to a page (in English when you press the Union Jack) from which you can download maps and routes, or plan your own route.
July 4, 2009 at 1:36 am
Groover
Here in Australia cycle lanes on intersections (few and far apart) are painted green, which indicates right of way. It’s strange that they are red in Germany, which would indicate “stop”, wouldn’t it?
July 4, 2009 at 10:23 am
Zweiradler
@ Groover:
Maybe red is more conspicuous than green.
As long as they indicate “stop” to the car drivers, everything’s fine.